Fox Sports Analyst Kenny Florian Accused of “Outrageous” Plagiarism

Posted: January 15, 2016 in Uncategorized

Update January 16, 2016– Fox Sports has now suspended Florian issuing the following statement:

It is vitally important that FOX Sports and FOXSports.com maintain credibility and trust with their readers, viewers and fans. FOX UFC on-air personality Kenny Florian is being suspended beginning immediately for a critical oversight in a story posted earlier this week on FOXSports.com. Florian has admitted and regrets his mistake and apologized for the error.

Update – Florian has issued the following apology –

Florian Apology

______________________

Analyzing fights is hard work and it takes special skill and great effort for individuals such as Robin Black and Jack Slack to provide their industry leading breakdowns.

Following similarities first noted by The Naked Gambler this week, former UFC fighter and current Fox Sports MMA analyst Kenny Florian has been accused of “outrageous” plagiarism by boxing analyst Lee Wylie.

Earlier this week Florian published a breakdown on FoxSpots.com of the upcoming bantamweight title bout between Dominic Cruz and TJ Dillashaw.  While discussing Dillashaw’s footwork Florian noted

On a fundamental level, the reason for the “step and slide” is simple. The less time a fighter stays airborne, the better his balance and the more economical his movement.

The problem?  On December 3, 2015 Wylie uploaded an analysis of boxer Willie Pep on YouTube with the following observation:

Screenshot Youtube fight breakdown

It doesn’t end there.

Florian also noted that “Everything in fighting begins and ends with the feet.” Where Wylie wrote as follows

Screenshot begins with feet

Florian – “This means he steps with his lead foot towards his opponent and then slides his rear foot the same distance to retain his base. There’s not much space between the soles of his feet and the canvas as he works to regulate distance and offset his opponent’s alignment.”

Wylie  –

Screenshot re alignment

Florian – “After circling to his left and ending in southpaw stance for example, he will abruptly step in and strike with a left hand just as his opponent begins to follow

Wylie –

Wylie Screenshot Abrutply

Florian – “Dillashaw relies on the inherently simplistic jab as the cornerstone of his arsenal more than Cruz

Wylie –

Screenshot re jab

The similarities go on.  Wylie, after having this brought to his attention called the actions ‘outrageous’

Screenshots Wylie Tweets

Florian’s article has since been updated with the following Editors Note

(Editor’s Note: Language in this breakdown borrows from written material in a video of an in-depth look at the defensive boxing prowess of Willie Pep by TheFightCity.com boxing analyst Lee Wylie. The original version of this story did not contain this credit. We regret the oversight.)

Florian has yet to publicly comment on this matter but has apparently apologized to Wylie and says he will clear the air on his podcast with Wylie taking the high road and accepting the apology.

Screenshot apology and acceptance tweets

It is unclear what Florian’s explanation is but for his sake hopefully he will clear the air sooner than next week as his actions are bringing swift condemnation by MMA’s online community

 

Screenshot tweet mocking Florian

Comments
  1. […] Wylie‘s Dec. 3 breakdown of 1940s boxer Willie Pep. Combat Sports Law has a good breakdown of all of the similarities between the two pieces. Here’s one of their many […]

  2. […] UFC bantamweight title fight between T.J. Dillashaw and Dominick Cruz. In it, Florian copied or reworded numerous sentences contained in a December video uploaded to YouTube by boxing analyst Lee […]

  3. billy says:

    best breakdown of his plagiarism out there. nice work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s