Why the Manitoba Commission’s Silence is Golden When it Comes to Fighter Injury Details

Posted: June 28, 2013 in Manitoba Combative Sports Commission, Uncategorized
Tags:

secret image

Following UFC 161 the Manitoba Combative Sports Commission released the required information relating to fighter medical suspensions so these can be published at the Association of Boxing Commissions Official Certified Database for Mixed Martial Arts.  This is done to allow Athletic Commissions in other jurisdictions to find out whether a combatant intending to fight under their watch is under medical suspension.

MCSC’s suspension list was quite barren on details.  The announced suspensions do little more than mention defined periods or ‘indefinite’ medical suspensions with no underlying information as to the injuries leading to these.  Why were Pat Barry and Rashad Evans suspended indefinitely?  What injuries did they sustain?  This lack of information brought criticism from some MMA fans with comments such as:

This is dumb, this has to be the least descriptive medical suspensions I’ve ever heard. I don’t know if it’s because it’s Canada but normally we get a really good breakdown of exactly what will keep guys out. I’m sure it’s just cause it’s Canada“.

Should the MCSC publicly release more information?  The answer is no for a number of reasons.

First off, while the Manitoba Boxing Regulation does require the Commission to hand out medical suspensions they are strictly prohibited from sharing details.  Section 49 of the Regulation reads as follows:

Except for the purpose of enforcing the Act and this regulation, the
commission and its members, employees and agents shall maintain confidentiality
with respect to any medical report, medical certificate, and any related medical
information in its or their possession.

In addition to this, Manitoba has, like most Canadian Jurisdictions, privacy legislation making those who breach the privacy of others subject lawsuits for damages.

Now if complying with the law is not enough, there are other practical reasons why the MCSC’s silence was the right thing to do.

Fighting is a competitive business.   As in all competitive industries, knowledge is power.   Imagine if a government official published something you were forced to share with them that can harm your interests with no right to do so?

What if Rashad had broken ribs?  What if Pat Barry sustained a knee injury?  Do you think their next competitors would benefit from this information?  Of course they would.  If you want proof just think back to the viscous body shots Alistair Overeem used to retire Brock Lesnar following his well publicized diverticulitis surgery.  Camps keep fighter injuries well guarded secrets for a reason.   Its in their fighter’s best interests.  To expect Commissions to publish this valuable information simply for the public’s hunger for details goes against the best interests of the people who make a living in this trade.

Keeping all of the above in mind the MSCS’s silence is golden.

About these ads
Comments
  1. They also post more details in the backend of the database, so other commissions can see what the issue was, or what was needed.

    Sometimes a guy will get an indefinate suspension cause his hand hurts, and all that’s needed is clearance on the injury, despite it not being serious. (But at the time, nobody knew what the damage was).

    The only suspension I was surprised with was Roy Nelson getting the default 14 day suspension (Manitoba’s minimum suspension for any MMA fighter). Nelson took a serious amount of damage in that fight, and I thought 2 weeks was too lenient.

    That being said, i’d never argue with a doctor (Or lawyer)

  2. EMagraken says:

    Roy is a freak of nature!

    Thanks for your comment MAD. I do appreciate that the back end of the database is more fulsome. This makes perfect sense for its intended purpose.

    Joel does a good job drawing a line in the sand and protecting fighter privacy. If they want their injury details aired they are free to do so but its not for the Commission to reveal this to the public at large.

  3. madrolet says:

    Exactly. The MCSC runs a tight ship, and they’ve always been consistent with their stance in this ever evolving combat sports game.

  4. […] Why the Manitoba Commission’s Silence is Golden When it Comes to Fighter Injury Details […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s